Following are this week's summaries of the Court of Appeal
for Ontario for the week of September 13, 2021.
In a very lengthy child custody/abduction/relocation
case, N. v. F., the Court upheld the trial
judge's decision to order that the parties' children be
returned to Dubai, as Ontario did not have jurisdiction to deal
with the custody issues. It was felt that on the balance of
probabilities, the children's best interests would be served by
their return to Dubai, so that a court there could adjudicate the
matters of custody, access, and guardianship. The Court confirmed
that significant deference must be paid to family law decisions,
and given the absence of a legal error or a palpable and overriding
error of fact or mixed fact and law, the Court should not
interfere. Lauwers J.A. dissented.