A Glimmer of Relief
A decision delivered on March 4, 2019 by the Québec Court
of Appeal in 9147-0732 Québec Inc. v. Director of
Criminal and Penal Prosecutions (2019) QCCA373 (CANLII)
suggests that proportionality may have more sway under the
Charter of Rights than under the Ontario Provincial
Offences Act (POA) in providing relief from mandatory minimum
fines.
The Current Relief under the POA
In the recent Ontario Court of Appeal case of R. v Henry of
Pelham 2018 ONCA 999 the Ontario Court of Appeal reversed two
lower court decisions granting relief to a corporate entity from a
mandatory minimum fine of $25,000 pursuant to ss.59(2) of the
Provincial Offences Act R.S.O. 1990, c.p.33. While the
lower courts regarded both the lack of a previous record, the early
guilty plea, the timely remediation offered and the inconsequential
nature of the offence as exceptional circumstances warranting
relief from the mandatory minimum fine, the Court of Appeal was
concerned