In Horri v The College of Physicians and
Surgeons, the Divisional Court reaffirms the importance of
consistency and justification when a professional regulator
sanctions one of its members. Penalties for misconduct should fall
within the range established by previous case law, and regulators
should exercise caution before departing from precedent on the
basis of "changing social values."
Dr. Mehdi Horri is a family physician who treated Patient A for
depression, anxiety and sleep difficulties. He had a total of
twelve treatment sessions with the patient over six months. During
this time, Patient A disclosed deeply personal information to Dr.
Horri.
Two weeks after the end of treatment, Dr. Horri and Patient A
commenced a sexual relationship that lasted approximately three
years. A report was subsequently made to the College.