A new case has just come down that should be of interest where
claims are made by infants or others under a disability and there
is a third party claim against a family member for their alleged
negligence relating to the incident, usually inadequate
supervision.
Homeowner's policies invariably contain an exclusion clause
that is intended by the insurer to prevent such claims from falling
within coverage for the allegedly negligent family member. In
the recent decision of Gill v Ivanhoe Cambridge, 2016 BCSC
252, Mr. Justice Voith refused to give effect to such an exclusion
and has granted coverage to a father whose two year old son was
injured at Metrotown when he found his way through a gap in the
glass adjacent to an escalator, resulting in a fall to the level
below and a significant injury. He held that the intention of
the exclusion was to prevent collusive claims among family members
and that the claim at issue was not collusive.