The recent woes of the estates bar in connection with multiple
Wills has been resolved positively by the Divisional Court's
decision in the Re Milne appeal decision issued on January
24, 2019.1
To recap the history of the saga, the starting point is that the
use of multiple wills, a standard technique used among estate
planning solicitors as a method of limiting the amount of probate
fees (now called Estate Administration Tax), took a beating in the
Re Milne2 decision of September 11, 2018. We
chronicled the initial decision in our
October 12, 2018 article.
The Re Milne decision was criticized by the estates bar
and estate academics as incorrect and, for several months, caused
pandemonium among the estates bar and their will clients. Some
measure of hope came on November 13, 2018 in the competing decision
of Re Panda, rendered by Justice Penny, described in our
article of December 5, 2018.
The main issue in both cases was whether discretionary clauses
(often