In a landmark decision released on January 31, 2019, the Supreme
Court of Canada (SCC) ruled in Orphan Well Association v Grant
Thornton Ltd. that the environmental remediation obligations
of a bankrupt oil and gas company must be fulfilled in priority
over all other claims, including secured claims. In addition to
immediate effects to creditors of Alberta oil and gas interests,
creditors of all sectors will want to analyze the implications of
this case.
Background
Under Alberta's regulatory regime, the licensing of active
wells is directly related to the management of liabilities for
closure and reclamation of inactive wells. Grant Thornton Limited
(GTL), serving as bankruptcy trustee for Redwater Energy
Corporation (Redwater), intended to take possession of
Redwater's active wells for the purpose of selling such assets
to pay secured creditors while disclaiming all inactive wells under
section 14.06 of the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act (BIA).
It was GTL's