Summary
In the fall of 2019, the Alberta Court of Appeal (the Court)
released its fifth procedural decision in Alberta's
Reference re Greenhouse Gas Pollution Pricing Act (the
Reference).1 The decision was in response to an
application by the intervenor, the David Suzuki Foundation (DSF),
to cross-examine Alberta's affiant, Mr. Robert Savage, on his
affidavit. While the Court had already granted Canada and British
Columbia permission to cross-examine Mr. Savage on his affidavit,
DSF argued it should also be permitted as its cross-examination
would relate specifically to the issue of a climate emergency.
Justice Slatter dismissed DSF's application on the grounds
that DSF had not proven that the benefit of its cross-examination
would outweigh the cost, that DSF had not established that such
cross-examination would materially assist the Court, and that
Canada and British Columbia will cross-examine the affiant on all
essential points. This decision is a reminder to