Pay for use or flat rates? Flat rates are often popular, but
they are poor public policy. Flat rates encourage waste. Flat rates
discourage conservation of water and energy, and devalue their
importance. Flat rates make conscientious citizens pay for the bad
habits of wasteful neighbours. And flat rates are generally too low
to pay for the full cost of the resources consumed. So flat water
rates are on their way out in Canada.
One of the key recommendations of the Walkerton water inquiry
was for full cost pricing of water. In 2009, the C.D. Howe
Institute also called for reform of municipal water pricing,
including the expanded use of water meters.1 Municipal
water agencies need billions of dollars in repairs to their
infrastructure. Worse, they severely underestimate how much it
costs to provide water services, earning only 70% of what they
spend. Full cost pricing should ensure that sufficient resources
are available for good facilities for water treatment