Two decisions were released by the Federal Court of Appeal in
the latter half of 2015 that came to seemingly opposite conclusions
regarding the role of the National Energy Board (NEB) in
considering the Crown's duty to consult First Nations peoples
who could be impacted by project development applications before
the NEB. Both cases received leave to appeal to the Supreme Court
of Canada, and on March 10, 2016, the Supreme Court
held that the two appeals will be heard together, meaning that
any discrepancies between the two decisions will have to be
clarified by the country's highest court.
In Hamlet
of Cyde River v TGS-NOPEC Geophysical Company ASA (TGS),
the Applicants were Inuit residents of a hamlet seeking judicial
review of the NEB's approval of a five-year offshore seismic
surveying project, arguing that the Crown's duty to consult the
Inuit was not properly fulfilled. The Applicants' argument
relied on two points: firstly, the nature of the project