Unionized employers regularly deal with employees alleging
breaches of their human rights. These allegations can be the
subject of the grievance process or an application
to the province's forum for hearings into human rights cases.
In Ontario, the forum is the Human Rights Tribunal; in Manitoba, it
is the Human Rights Commission.
You'll see that I underlined the word
"or" in the last paragraph. It seems
reasonable that an employer should only be required to answer these
allegations in one forum, doesn't it? And a recent Manitoba
Court of Queen's Bench decision says the right forum is the
grievance process.1
The facts of the case were straightforward: an employee alleged
that the termination of her employment was a failure to accommodate
her disability (alcoholism). The termination was the subject of a
grievance, which was referred to arbitration. However, before the
grievance arbitration hearing began, a Memorandum of Agreement
("MoA") was negotiated, the grievor