I recently had reason to reconsider the question of whether, in Ontario, there is a two-year or no limitation period for sexual assault where one of the parties to the alleged assault has died. I wanted to know if there had been further case law developments on this question since my 2016 blog on the topic, “Court Breaks New Ground for Sexual Assault Cases.” I was surprised to see that, ten years later, the question has yet to be answered in a clear and conclusive manner. There are lessons to be drawn from this state of affairs, which I offer at the end.
The decision addressed in my 2016 blog was Fox v. Narine, 2016 ONSC 6499, which had just been released at the time. This case was based on a Rule 21 motion brought by the defendant to strike the claim by the estate of a deceased victim of sexual assault, where the claim had been started two years and two days after the victim’s death. The court declined to strike the claim and allowed the action to continue. There is no reported