What happens when, in a closely-held company of three or more
shareholders, the working relationship between two of the
shareholders (only), has eroded so irreparably that the dysfunction
has stymied the company's business? Is it possible to include
enforceable selective remedies in shareholders' agreements that
offer a path forward without neutral, non-disputing shareholders
having to choose sides? i.e. this dispute is between the
two of us, and one of us has to go.
We recently considered this issue and whether buy-sell shotgun
provisions that operate between specific shareholders to the
exclusion of others are enforceable. For the purposes of this
discussion, such provisions will be referred to as
"selective shotgun" provisions or
clauses. The question uncovered an interesting change in the
drafting of shotgun provisions over the past three decades.