In Durham Sports Barn Inc. Bankruptcy Proposal,
2020 ONSC 5938 (Durham), the Ontario Superior Court of Justice (the
Court) found in favour of the landlord when interpreting a
commercial lease's force majeure clause in
the context of a tenant seeking relief from the obligation to pay
rent when it was statutorily prevented from operating due to
COVID-19.
Background
Durham Sports Barn Inc. (the Tenant) operates an athletic
performance centre at a building in Oshawa, Ontario (the Leased
Premises). 1213423 Ontario Inc. (the Landlord) rented the Leased
Premises to the Tenant for 10 years commencing at the end of 2015
pursuant to two leases (the Leases). Due to public health mandated
closures of non-essential businesses in light of the pandemic, the
Tenant closed for business from March 18, 2020 until May 25, 2020.
The Tenant began a phased re-opening from May 25, 2020 to July 25,
2020, and resumed full operations in August. The Landlord did not
apply for any federal