The WTO has recently ruled against Canada in a dispute started
by Brazil, which alleges that Bombardier Inc.'s C-Series
aircrafts are receiving unfair subsidies from the Canadian
government. According to Brazil, Bombardier Inc. and its suppliers
have received billions in subsidies, which are allegedly against
Canada's WTO obligations and have hurt Brazil's aviation
industry. Notably, Brazil-based Embraer S.A. is one of Bombardier
Inc.'s major competitors.
A dispute panel was established at the WTO when a month of
consultations failed to resolve Brazil's complaint. Canada
objected to Brazil's panel request for three main reasons, and
the panel disagreed with Canada on all three.
First, Canada argued that, in its panel request, Brazil failed
to provide a summary of the legal basis for the prejudice that it
claims that it is experiencing. In particular, Canada argued that
Brazil had not clearly identified the allegedly subsidized product
and the corresponding like