Performance claims can be an effective way of advertising a
product and comparing it to competitors. But the Competition Act
prohibits making performance claims not based on an adequate and
proper test. Two recent cases highlight the dangers inherent in
this provision for advertisers.
The first involved Rogers Communcations Inc. Rogers' claims
that customers of its Chatr brand experienced fewer dropped calls
than those of the new entrants were not false or misleading, the
Ontario Superior Court held recently in dismissing, in large part,
an application by the commissioner of competition.
The court did find, however, that Rogers had breached the
performance claims provision of the Competition Act, because it did
not conduct adequate and proper tests before making certain
representations in Calgary, Edmonton, and Montreal.