The Competition Tribunal denied leave for a public interest
applicant to commence a private proceeding against Google and Apple
regarding Google's dominance in search in Martin v. Alphabet.
In this first case considering leave for a public interest
applicant, the Tribunal applied a modified version of the
established public interest test, considering whether (1) there was
a substantial and genuine competition law issue, (2) the applicant
had a genuine interest in the matter, and (3) the proposed
proceeding was a reasonable and effective way to resolve the
dispute.
The leave application failed on the second and third steps of
the test. The Tribunal found that although the applicant operated a
business that uses and relies on Google's search engine, he
failed to lead sufficient evidence to show that he had a genuine
interest in whether and how the general search engine market in
Canada operated efficiently, competitively, and in the interests of
consumers, or that