In two recent cases, the British Virgin Islands Commercial Court
had the opportunity to clarify the effect of section 125 of the
Evidence Act 2006 (the Act). This
provides that the Court is obliged to carry out a balancing act
between the manner in which the evidence was obtained and the
desirability of admitting it.
In Tall Trade Ltd v Capital WW Investment Limited,
Justice Jack ruled that the hacking of someone's computer or
server is a serious impropriety and rendered the evidence
inadmissible. Importantly, the Court highlighted that alternatively
the evidence could have been obtained by lawful means.
In this case, the Respondent contested an application for the
appointment of a liquidator on the basis that it was initiated for
an improper purpose ie a conspiracy against it. To prove this
conspiracy, the Respondent relied on Telegram text messages it had
received from a telecommunications company. In assessing the
evidence that was before it, the learned judge