The issue of confidentiality orders, and when they will be
granted, is a frequent topic particularly in the context of trust
law. The approach of the Bermuda courts in granting confidentiality
orders in trust matters is often contrasted with the stricter
approach currently taken by the English Courts.
In Director for Public Prosecutions -v- Cindy Clarke
[2019] CA (Bda) 8 Civ, 21 June 2019, the Bermuda Court of Appeal
considered the proper approach to confidentiality orders in
judicial review. There has been a concern in Bermuda that the
generous approach of the Bermuda courts towards confidentiality
orders in trust actions has spilled over into ordinary civil
litigation. In DPP -v- Cindy Clarke, which concerned a
judicial review of internal disciplinary proceedings within the
Department of Public Prosecutions, the Bermuda Supreme Court had
granted confidentiality orders because the internal proceedings had
been private proceedings. The Court of Appeal strongly