A recent Federal Court case has again shown how difficult it is
to prove if someone providing services is an independent contractor
or an employee – and how expensive getting this wrong can
be.
Justice Bromberg's decision in On Call Interpreters and
Translators Agency Pty Ltd v Commissioner of Taxation (No 3) [2011]
FCA 366 is a useful restatement of the main principles, but it also
shows the problems a company can have in establishing the nature of
its relationship with service providers that it considers to be
independent contractors.
The translators, the tax man, and the superannuation guarantee
charge
On Call provides interpretation and translation services.
Essentially, it takes a request from a client and then matches the
job to an interpreter or translator on its panel. That person is
free to reject the job (and often will) and to undertake work
provided by rival companies, but cannot negotiate the rate at which
he or she is paid for work that comes via