A gesture of goodwill from the ATO - No goodwill, no
consideration, no worries?
Think again - Herding professionals down a narrow path!
On 16 March 2011, the Commissioner released a draft tax
determination TD 2011/D3 – Market value of nil for shares
in a 'no goodwill' incorporated professional practice
("IPP") [sic].
This ruling extends on the Commissioner's existing
ruling IT 2540 (released in 1989) that accepted that the so-called
"market value substitution rule" should not apply in
relation to the disposal of partnership interest (held by natural
persons) where the interest is disposed of for no consideration and
the parties were acting at arms length.
In our view this determination (if finalised as it is) will have
little to no beneficial application to practitioners looking to
move in or out of a IPP and arguably puts the industry on notice
for those that have disposed of interests in IPP's shares
and have not declared a capital gain.