RM Brothers Pty Ltd v SEBT Pty Ltd; SEBT Pty Ltd v R M
Brothers & Morris [2017] NSWCATCD 43
In this case, the water supply to the premises was never
adequate for the lessee to operate a self-serve frozen yogurt
business. The lessor disclosed that the lessee would need to
install a pump to obtain an adequate water supply to the premises,
and that this was how the previous tenant operated. The lessee
acknowledged this, and entered into the lease. The lessee was never
able to obtain an adequate water supply and did not open for trade.
The lessor terminated for failure to pay rent and claimed
damages.
The Lessor's Disclosure Statement included: "Water
connection and associated drainage works as set out in clause 31 of
the Lease". Clause 31(a) provided that at the commencing date
"the Premises is not connected to the water supply and
associated drainage of the building" and that the Lessee was
permitted at its expense to arrange "a direct water connection
to the