Following a unanimous verdict in his favour in June
2022, Johnny Depp said that 'the jury gave me my life
back'.
That might be thought a strange thing to say. It seems to
suggest the verdict was not inevitable but some sort of gift; one
which was given voluntarily and therefore might have been withheld.
It reveals an uncomfortable reality about juries - they have a
choice. And if they have a choice, they (or a different jury) might
have decided otherwise.
Johnny Depp's defamation proceeding against Amber Heard was
tried by a jury of seven in the Fairfax County Circuit Court in
Virginia (although, because it was live streamed, it was
effectively also tried by many millions of other people around the
world, who could watch snippets of the testimony online and then
reach and share their own 'verdicts' in the court of public
opinion).