The policy behind the statutory defence of proportionate
liability is at least in part to alleviate the prospect of a
defendant unfairly bearing the entirety of a plaintiff's
commercial loss, in circumstances where it is only responsible for
a small proportion of that loss. The corollary is, perhaps, that
the defence should not be cast aside lightly.
In Queensland, it is not possible for parties to agree to forego
their statutory recourse to a proportionate liability defence. In
respect of the Victoria, South Australia, Australian Capital
Territory, Northern Territory and Commonwealth provisions, the
legislation is silent. In New South Wales, Western Australia and
Tasmania, parties are entitled to agree to contract out of the
defence, in certain circumstances. The recently released Model
Provisions favour a prohibition on contracting out of proportionate
liability, except in limited circumstances14.