Fulmer v Thompson [2017] QSC 119
Introduction
Expert witnesses have an obligation to act independently and
objectively. This case provides an example of an expert witness who
actively strategised with the defendants' solicitor to shape
the defence of the case, which ultimately cost him his
credibility.
There were also problems with the reliability and basis of the
evidence provided by the expert, including that the accounting
documents relied upon by the expert had not been separately
accepted as evidence.
Background
The plaintiff, Peter Fulmer, an experienced car salesman,
commenced working for Australian Motors, a used vehicle sales
business, in 2003. Australian Motors was owned by the third
defendant, Caysand No 24 Pty Ltd ('Caysand 24').