The recent split decision of the High Court of
Australia1 in relation to the patentability of
computer-implemented inventions will be elucidated by further
Federal Court decisions. In the meantime, it is possible to discern
significant points of common ground between the rival pro- and
anti-patentability reasons, and some preliminary
learnings.
No advance in computer technology required
It is not necessary for a computer-implemented invention to
result in an 'advance in computer technology' to be
patentable. This question had arisen as Aristocrat had sought to
patent an electronic gaming machine which implemented free
'feature games' when certain conditions were
met.2
The Commissioner of Patents had refused Aristocrat's
application on the basis that the claimed invention did not concern
a 'manner of manufacture' (Australia's requirement for
patentable subject matter),3 as the substance of the
invention was a mere scheme (being a game and game rules of a
gaming