One recent product liability case looks at the distinction
between an 'occurrence' and 'damage' in a liability
policy: Selected Seeds Pty Ltd v QBEMM Pty Ltd [2009] QSC 70. A
second case confirms that the onus is on a plaintiff not only to
establish damage, but to show that the damage resulted from the
fault of the defendant: Thirlway v Parnell LP Gas Systems Pty Ltd
[2009] WADC 36.
Selected Seeds Pty Ltd v QBEMM Pty LTD [2009] QSC
70
Facts
In 2002, Selected Seeds Pty Ltd, a seed merchant, purchased an
amount of seeds which it believed was 'Jarra grass'.
However, Selected Seeds was in fact supplied with an inferior and
different type of seed known as 'Summer grass'.
Selected Seeds supplied these seeds to various intermediaries
before some of the seeds were eventually acquired by Mr and Mrs
Shrimp (the Shrimps). The Shrimps planted the seeds on their land
believing them to be Jarra grass. However, when they discovered it
was Summer grass the Shrimps instituted