Judgment date: 6 February 2012
Ridolfi v Hammond [2012] NSWCA
31
New South Wales Court of Appeal
In Brief
- Where competing medical opinions arise in relation to the role
of a pre-existing condition, considerable weight should,
ordinarily, be attached to those of doctors who treated a claimant
prior to the accident.
- In determining whether a defendant has discharged its
evidential onus of disentanglement of pre-existing conditions, the
court is required to evaluate possibilities, not proof on a balance
of probabilities.
Background
On 28 August 2000, the plaintiff was injured when his stationary
vehicle was rear ended at high speed. He suffered a whiplash
injury. Two months after the accident, the progressive neurological
condition known as myelomalacia was diagnosed. In issue was the
cause of that condition, on a background of pre-existing disc
disease.