Assessing life insurance claims is a careful balancing act,
weighing up the opinions of various medical experts and vocational
assessors. Dotlic v Hannover Life Re of Australasia
Limited [2017] NSWSC 986 provides some much needed colour to
the shades of grey insurers face when considering expert
evidence.
The Accident
Mr Dotlic immigrated from Bosnia to Australia in 2000 at the age
of 19. He found work as a formwork labourer and became a member of
the Construction and Building Unions Superannuation Fund, which was
party to a group life policy issued by Hannover Life Re Australasia
Limited (Hannover).
In 2009, Mr Dotlic was involved in a motor vehicle accident,
suffering only minor head, shoulder and back injuries. He was
admitted to hospital and released the same day. The extent of his
treatment was physiotherapy and massage on referral from his
general practitioner.