Introduction
In this case, Justice McDougall of the New South Wales Supreme
Court considered whether, pursuant to s 28(3) of the Insurance
Contracts Act 1984 (Cth), Atradius Credit Insurance
NV (Atradius) was entitled to reduce its liability
under the policy to nil, on the basis of non-fraudulent
misrepresentation.
His Honour held that on the balance of probabilities, had
Atradius been given truthful and complete answers in response to
its insurance proposal, it would not have issued the policy and was
entitled to reduce its liability to nil.
Background
Atradius issued a trade credit insurance policy in favour of
Prepaid Services Pty Limited, Optus Mobile Pty Limited and Virgin
Mobile (Australia) Pty Limited (the Insured). The
policy insured against the insolvency of one of the Insured's
major debtors, a company known as Bill Express Limited
(BXP), and against BXP's failure to pay
amounts owing to any of the Insureds. BXP became insolvent and the
Insured