On 15 September 2011, the extent of cover available for defence
costs under a directors and officers (D&O) policy was thrown
into doubt by the New Zealand High Court in Steigrad & Ors
v BFSL2007 Ltd & Ors HC Auckland CIV-2011-404-611. The
High Court relied on section 9 of the Law Reform Act 1936
(NZ) in deciding that the former Bridgecorp directors could not
rely on their D&O policy to meet the cost of defending civil
and criminal claims against them. Several Australian states have
similar legislation.
In the High Court, Lang J held that the charge created by
section 9 applies to the entire sum insured available for both
liability and defence costs cover. Thus, where the potential
liability the insured is facing to a claimant exceeds the sum
insured, the charge exhausts the sum insured and nothing is left to
pay defence costs in the meantime.