Is This Packaging A Trick Or A Treat?

During the Halloween season, some consumers went to the store and bought a bag of Reese's Peanut Putter Pumpkins. The packaging featured pictures of pumpkin-shaped Reese's peanut butter cups, with jack-o-lantern faces carved onto the front of them. Next to the image, there's a disclaimer that says, “DECORATING SUGGESTION.” The packaging looks like this: 

When the consumers opened the package, however, the product didn't have carved faces. Instead, the product looked like this: 

The consumers sued for false advertising, alleging that Hershey misled consumers about what the product actually looks like. As the court explained, the plaintiffs alleged that “Hersey represented that its Reese's Peanut Butter Pumpkins product had explicit carved-out artistic designs of a mouth and eyes on their surface when there are no such carved designs on the actual chocolate products."