Eleventh Circuit Slaps Down Bank's Third Attempt To Compel Arbitration In Overdraft Litigation Fight

The Eleventh Circuit recently upheld a district court's denial of RBC Bank's latest attempt to compel arbitration of a dispute with banking customers over allegedly fraudulent overdraft practices. The bank had previously lost its bid to enforce the arbitration provision in a 2008 customer account agreement ("CAA"). PNC Bank, which had acquired RBC, issued a new CAA in 2012 that lacked an arbitration provision and purported to be binding on account holders who did not opt out. The lower court then denied RBC's renewed motion to compel arbitration based on the 2008 CAA, finding the 2012 CAA superseded the 2008 CAA. Shortly thereafter, PNC distributed a 2013 amended CAA including an arbitration provision that purported to apply retroactively to existing claims and to be binding on account holders who did not opt out. The present opinion came in review of the district court's subsequent denial of another motion to compel arbitration, this one based upon the 2013 CAA,