As the body of institution and final decisions in inter
partes review (IPR) trials grows, useful trends at both
decision stages can be identified. One emerging trend is the
relative likelihood that two petitions attacking one or more of the
same claims will be more likely granted if filed in parallel
(multiple petitions, simultaneously, on the same patent) as
compared to when filed serially (multiple petitions, consecutively,
on the same patent).
While the decision on whether to institute a trial is always up
to the Board's discretion under 35 U.S.C. § 314(a)
(see, e.g., IPR2013-00324, Paper 19, at 4 (PTAB Nov. 21,
2013)), serial petitions where the same or substantially the same
prior art or arguments have already been presented to the office
face an additional statutory hurdle under 35 U.S.C. § 325(d)
(which provides the PTAB with discretion to reject a petition where
"the same or substantially" the same prior art is at
issue in a separate proceeding before the