Too often some challenger in IPR declines to use non-patent
literature (or "NPL"), such as academic and trade journal
articles, because of the effort and risk associated with
establishing that the NPL is prior art. The Federal Circuit's
recent decision in Telefonaktiebolaget LM Ericsson V. TCL
Corp. (No. 17-2381) illustrates why that strategy can be a
mistake and provides guidance on how to use NPL effectively.
As
we have discussed, the PTAB often imposes specific requirements for
establishing that an NPL reference is a prior art printed
publication. Unlike with patent prior art,
where challengers can ordinarily rely on the dates on the document
itself, challengers typically have to introduce evidence that NPL
was publicly accessible early enough to make it prior art. Getting
that evidence can be challenging, which is why some challengers shy
away from using NPL at all.