Addressing whether either of two previously filed district court
actions precluded institution of an inter partes review
(IPR) proceeding under the one-year time bar of 35 USC §
315(b), the Patent Trial and Appeal Board (PTAB) held that the bar
does not apply to voluntary dismissals without prejudice under Fed.
R. Civ. P. 41(a) because such a dismissal effectively nullifies the
very existence of the prior action. Superior Comms., Inc. v.
Volstar Tech., Inc., Case No. IPR2017-00067 (PTAB, Apr. 20,
2018) (Zado, APJ).
During an IPR proceeding, the patent owner, Volstar
Technologies, asserted that the PTAB should have denied institution
under § 315(b) because the petitions were filed more than one
year after the petitioner (Superior Communications), the real
party-in-interest or the petitioner's privy was served with a
patent infringement complaint. Volstar identified two prior
district court actions asserting infringement of the challenged
patent that it contended gave