The Federal Circuit definitively rejected arguments to cancel
challenged claims for reasons other than anticipation or
obviousness in an inter partes review
proceeding.1 In Samsung Electronics America,
Inc., v. Prisua Engineering Corp.,2 the Federal
Circuit rejected Samsung’s challenge that the PTAB has
authority to cancel claims it has found indefinite in an
IPR.
After being sued for infringing U.S. Patent 8,650,591 (assigned
to Prisua), Samsung filed an IPR petition3 challenging
claims 1-4, 8, and 11 of the ’591 patent.4
The Board initially instituted the IPR only on the ground
challenging claim 11 as obvious over a published U.S. patent
application. The Board explained it did not institute on any
ground challenging claims 1-4 and 8, because it could not determine
the scope of those claims, which were indefinite under 35 U.S.C.
§ 112, paragraph 2 in accordance with the analysis set forth
in IPXL5 and 35 U.S.C. § 112,
paragraph 6.6 While the IPR was