Back In December I pointed out that the SCOTUS would
likely tighten the PTAB appeal bar in Dex Media Inc. v.
Click-To-Call Technologies, LP, explaining that, based on the
oral argument, that several justices of the Court seemed to take
the view that technical violations, such as 315(b) were too closely
related to the institution determination of the agency. For
example, Justices Kagan and Ginsburg explained it would be "a
little bit silly to go back to square one" and that there was
"something unseemly about nullifying the determination on the
merits." (transcript
here)
Today's majority decision, authored by Justice Ginsburg,
presented no surprises.
As a reminder, Dex Media considered whether
disputed violations
of 35 U.S.C. § 315(b) are barred from appeal
under 35 U.S.C. 315(d). perhaps most succinctly, today's
decision (
here) explained: