Suffolk Techs., LLC v. AOL Inc.
Addressing the standard for establishing that an alleged prior
art reference qualifies as a "printed publication," the
U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit affirmed summary
judgment that a non-indexed, non-searchable newsgroup post
invalidated a patent, finding that a printed publication does not
need to be easily located to qualify as prior art.
Suffolk Techs., LLC v. AOL Inc., Case No. 13-1392 (Fed.
Cir., May 27, 2014) (Prost, J.)
Suffolk sued AOL and Google on a patent directed to controlling
a server that supplies files to computers that render web
pages. The alleged invalidating reference was a 1995 posting
in an online newsgroup (Post). A college student authored the
Post to answer a question posed by another user. Although the
newsgroup's policy was to alter each entry's timestamp and
e-mail address to protect its users from spambots, the author
authenticated the substance of his response. After the
district