[This guest post was written by Kira-Khanh McCarthy, a rising-3L
at University of Notre Dame Law School.] The Board reversed a
Section 2(e)(5) refusal to register the package configuration mark
shown below, for "canned fish; tinned fish." The mark is
described as: "a three dimensional trade dress design of a
package of the Applicant's goods. The three dimensional product
packaging is in the shape of a cylinder. The top of the product
packaging is a transparent circle, represented by vertical lines,
through which the product is seen. The solid portions represent
opaque areas."
The Examining Attorney contended that "the transparent
portion of the packaging serves a functional and utilitarian
purpose, namely, allowing consumers to view or inspect the
goods." As an alternative argument, he also refused
registration on the ground that Applicant failed to prove that the
applied-for mark had acquired distinctiveness under Section 2(f).
Although the Board reversed the