Ineos USA LLC v. Berry Plastics Corp.
Addressing anticipation under pre-AIA § 102 in the context
of a claimed numerical range and prior art disclosing a broader,
overlapping range, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal
Circuit affirmed a lower court's summary judgment ruling of
invalidity noting that the patent owner failed to raise a genuine
question of fact about whether the claimed range was critical to
the operability of the invention. Ineos USA LLC v. Berry
Plastics Corp., Case No. 14-0540 (Fed. Cir., Apr. 16, 2015)
(Moore, J.)
Ineos is the owner of a patent relating to polyethylene-based
compositions used to form shape products, including screw caps for
bottles. Prior art screw cap polyethylene compositions employed
lubricants to enhance slip properties, but also imparted an odor
issue and a flavor to contacted food products. The patent
purportedly eliminated the odor and flavor problems, claiming
specific amounts of polyethylene, lubricants and additives.