ABB, Inc. v. ROY-G-BIV Corp.
In a final written decision, the U.S. Patent and Trademark
Office's Patent Trial and Appeal Board (PTAB) commented that
evidence can only be excluded by properly serving a notice and
filing a motion to exclude, but that a motion to exclude is not the
proper vehicle to dispute the scope of arguments and evidence in a
reply. ABB, Inc. v. ROY-G-BIV Corp., Case IPR2013-00063
(PTAB, May 16, 2014) (Giannetti, APJ).
Petitioner ABB requested an inter partes review (IPR)
of claims of a patent owned by ROY-G-BIV. The claimed
invention relates to a system for facilitating the creation of
hardware-independent software for controlling mechanical
systems. This case is one of a series of related IPRs (
IP Update , Vol. 17, No. 5). As in other cases in this
series, the PTAB held that the prior art references failed to
satisfy two of the claim limitations.