Cisco Sys., Inc. v. C-Cation Techs
In a decision recently designated as "informative" and
addressing the issue of using footnotes to cite to a 200-plus-page
declaration to support conclusory statements in an inter
partes (IPR) review petition, the Patent Trial and Appeal
Board (PTAB or Board) refused to consider arguments that were not
explicitly made in the petition. Cisco Sys., Inc. v.
C-Cation Techs., LLC, Case IPR2014-00454 (PTAB, Aug. 29, 2014)
(Droesch, APJ).
The petitioner filed a petition to institute an inter
partes review of a patent. The petition used footnotes
to cite large portions of a 200-plus-page expert declaration.
For example, a seven-page section of the petition cited 17 pages of
the declaration. Claim charts in the petition cited other
claim charts in the declaration. The Board further found that
"the petition include[d] citations to the declaration to
support conclusory statements for which the petition [did] not
otherwise provide an