The US Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit vacated and
remanded a decision of the Patent Trial and Appeal Board (PTAB),
holding certain claims to be not obvious where the PTAB failed to
consider record evidence that might have established that certain
prior art was analogous to the claimed invention. Airbus S.A.S.
v. Firepass Corp., Case No. 19-1803 (Fed. Cir. Nov. 8, 2019)
(Stoll, J).
Firepass owns a patent on a fire prevention and suppression
system that involves using oxygen-depleted but still-breathable
(hypoxic) air in a sealed room. Airbus petitioned for an inter
partes re-examination proceeding, asserting (as prior art) a
reference by the same inventor (Kotliar) that involved using
hypoxic air for athletic training. Airbus also asserted four
additional prior art references relating to fire suppression and/or
human performance in hypoxic atmospheres. As part of the
re-examination, Firepass submitted new claims to be examined, and
the examiner rejected each