Lexmark International, Inc. v. Impression Products,
Inc. (No. 2014-1617, 2/12/16) (en banc)
February 12, 2016 4:11 PM
Taranto, J. En banc decision reaffirming holdings of earlier
CAFC decisions regarding patent exhaustion in light of recent
Supreme Court cases: 1) "a patentee, when
selling a patented article subject
to a single-use/no-resale restriction that is lawful and
clearly communicated to the purchaser, does not by that sale give
the buyer, or downstream buyers, the resale/reuse authority that
has been expressly denied;" and 2) "a U.S. patentee,
merely by selling or authorizing the sale of a U.S.-patented
article abroad, does not authorize the buyer to import the article
and sell and use it in the United States." "A buyer may
still rely on a foreign sale as a defense to infringement,
but only by establishing an express
or implied license—a defense separate from exhaustion,
as Quanta holds—based on patentee
communications or other