The Federal Circuit on Wednesday reversed Court precedent and
long held belief that inter partes review ("IPR")
institution decisions were categorically non-reviewable. The Court,
sitting en banc, held that the issue of whether a petitioner is
time-barred from filing an IPR petition under 35 U.S.C.
§ 315(b) is in fact reviewable.1
This case arose when the patent owner alleged that an IPR
petition was time barred based on the petitioner being privy with
parties sued over the patent more than a year before the petition
was filed. The IPR was instituted and a final written decision was
published.
Congress granted the Director of the USPTO, subject to certain
requirements, the sole discretion in whether to institute an
IPR. It is the extent of that discretion that the Court
clarified on Wednesday. The Court honed in on two sections of the
AIA—§§ 314 and 315. Section 314(a) authorizes the
Director to institute an IPR if there is a "reasonable
likelihood" that the