In Raytheon Technologies
v. General Electric Corp., Appeal 2020-1755,
(Fed. Cir. April 16, 2021), the Federal Circuit reversed a PTAB
inter partes review decision that determined
Raytheon's claims, directed to gas turbine engines, are
unpatentable as obviousness over "Knip," a 1987 NASA
technical memo. In particular, the court determined that Knip
did not enable a skilled artisan to make the claimed invention.
The Raytheon patent generally claims a gas turbine engine
having, among other things, "a power density at Sea Level
Takeoff greater than or equal to 1.5 lbf/in3 and less
than or equal to 5.5 lbf/in3." The key
distinguishing feature of Raytheon's claims, according to the
PTAB, was that power density range, which "the patent
describe[d] as being 'much higher than in the prior
art.'" Id. at 4 (citing the Raytheon
patent).