On an issue of first impression in a copyright infringement
dispute out of the Southern District of Texas, the US Court of
Appeals for the Fifth Circuit confirmed that failure to mitigate is
not a complete defense to copyright or Digital Millennium Copyright
Act (DMCA) claims for statutory damages. Energy Intelligence
Grp., Inc. et. al., v. Kayne Anderson Capital Advisors, LP, et.
al., Case No. 18-20350 (5th Cir., January 15, 2020)
(Higginson, J.).
In 2014, energy industry publisher Energy Intelligence Group,
Inc. and its affiliated entity in the United Kingdom (together,
EIG) filed suit against energy securities investment firm Kayne
Anderson Capital Advisers (KA), alleging copyright infringement and
abuses of the DMCA based on a KA partner's violation of US
copyright law and violation of his subscription agreement for
EIG's Oil Daily newsletter, which provides news and
analysis about the North America petroleum industry. The jury in
the district court proceeding