Software patents have been under fire so much that the courts
now appear sympathetic when invalidating the claims as lacking
patentable subject matter. A recent case out of the Southern
District of New York emphasized the judge's appreciation of the
invention and how "clever" the invention truly was. Alas,
the court still invalidated the claims as being patent
ineligible.
The case of Stanacard, LLC v. Rubard, LLC, Case No.
1:12-cv-05176 (S.D.N.Y. November 18, 2015) relates to a call
forwarding system that simplifies and reduces the cost of making
long distance and international calls. The system provides a ten
digit number to an end user, which the end user can call from a
designated phone to reach a previously designated recipient. For
example, the telephone service provider can provide a number
555-123-4567 to an end user, and the end user can associate that
number with the mother of the end user. When the end user wishes to
call his mother, he can simply dial the