Share on LinkedInShare on LinkedIn

ARTICLE · 04 JUNE 2013

Design Patent Functionality After Egyptian Goddess And Richardson: The Assumption Of Claim Construction Dysfunction And Gumption

The Federal Circuit’s decisions in Egyptian Goddess v. Swisa and Richardson v. Stanley Works have afforded district courts considerable discretion regarding how to assess functional features of claimed designs in the context of infringement.

United StatesIntellectual Property

The Federal Circuit's decisions in Egyptian Goddess v. Swisa and Richardson v. Stanley Works have afforded district courts considerable discretion regarding how to assess functional features of claimed designs in the context of infringement. Setting aside the threshold question of whether such evaluations are proper in the context of claim construction (versus being affirmative defenses), a matter which has been discussed extensively, the lack of clear signposts through the functionality thicket is injecting significant uncertainty into design patent litigation.

To make matters more complicated, the signposts that do exist are not always pointing in the same directions. Indeed, Richardson's use of varied language to describe how to consider functional elements in design patents, words such as "ignoring" and "factoring out," present further uncertainty. Indeed, it seems conceivable within the purview of Richardson that a court—armed with wide discretion—could

We operate a free-to-view policy, asking only that you register in order to read all of our content. Please login or register to view the rest of this article.

See more popular content from