Valeo, Inc. v. Magna Electronics, Inc.
In an Order on Conduct of the Proceedings, the U.S. Patent and
Trademark Office's Patent Trial and Appeal Board (PTAB or
Board) denied a patent owner's request to depose a
petitioner's declarant whose declarations had been served but
not made of record. Valeo, Inc. v. Magna Electronics,
Inc., Case Nos. IPR2014-00221, -00227 (PTAB, Nov. 13, 2014)
(Clements, APJ).
In a Petitioner's Reply to Patent Owner Response, the
petitioner submitted new evidence that it contended was directly
responsive to arguments made by the patent owner in its Patent
Owner Response and directed to the credibility of the patent
owner's expert, rather than to bolster the underlying grounds
of unpatentability on which the IPR was instituted. The
patent owner disagreed with the petitioner's characterization
and further asserted that one of the cited references did not
constitute prior art. The Board reserved the issue of whether
the new evidence was